In October 2007, two teenage boys, Michael Turner and Caleb Hale, vanished from a small West Virginia town and were found murdered the next day. Their high school football coach, Dan Whitaker, was arrested and sentenced to life in prison, though he has always claimed innocence. Investigators also looked at Caleb’s uncle, Justin Hale, who had no alibi and a rumored motive, but he was never charged. Some locals still suspect a drifter who may have slipped away unnoticed. Voices of Devil’s Branch unravels the trial, lingering doubts, and three competing theories that continue to haunt the community.